Bukid Apo: 2010

Wednesday, April 28, 2010

This summary is not available. Please click here to view the post.

Photo by Romy Elusfa

Forensic Investigation? PDF Print E-mail
Posted Tuesday, 01 December 2009

Commentary by Alan Davis

Photo by Romy Elusfa
Photo by Romy Elusfa
B
elieve it or not, this photograph (right) does not capture the Maguindanao crime scene. No, this picture actually shows the official recovery of bodies. This is forensic investigation SOCO-style. The photojournalist who took this, Romy Elusfa, a human rights reporting colleague has confirmed to us that this picture was taken during the actual and official recovery process.

It simply beggars belief.

2,000-year-old Romans buried in Pompeii who are nobody’s relations were afforded far more respectful treatment by archeologists than the victims of last week’s massacre.

Perhaps no SOCO (Scene of the Crime Operatives) official at the site has ever seen an episode of CSI – but whatever happened to basic training --or even simple basic humanity?

The duty of SOCO is to secure the scene and recover and document evidence. It is not a race against the clock. And when we are talking about such an atrocity, a mass killing such as this, you cannot exaggerate the duty and level of care and attention needed.

The person captured in Romy’s photo is a victim twice over: First when he was killed and secondly when the authorities used a backhoe to recover his remains.

As well as being an affront to common decency, such a blunt way of ‘recovery’ will inevitably destroy evidence and therefore quite possibly impact on the future legal cases.

How stupid and unthinking can some people be?

Last Friday in Southern Mindanao – and before coming across this photo - I met with a forensic consultant who works for several human rights and legal groups and who was in Maguindanao as an observer. He told me that he had offered his advice as well as some expert equipment he had arranged to be lent by colleagues in Cotabato City. The authorities turned him down. They didn’t need his help.

Obviously: Who needs expert equipment and advice when you have a backhoe handy.

Let’s at least hope it was not the same digger used by the killers – but then who knows? After seeing Romy’s photo I think I can believe anything. Philippine Human Rights Reporting Project

(The author is the director of the Philippine Human Rights Reporting Project and the Head of Asia of the Institute for War and Peace Reporting.)

Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)

Welcome to my Blog

This Blog is intended to publish some of my news articles as a freelance journalist.

This has also been designed to show some other services I offer to friends and clients, among them are:
1) Events organizing
2) Organizing tours in Mindanao. It can be to tourist destinations in Southern Philippines or other specific locations and interests, like farms, media coverage in specific areas in the island, and the likes.
3) Vehicle rental
4) Photo and video documentary production
5) Communications-related consulting jobs

News Archieve

From The Times November 28, 2009 Philippines massacre: women thought they were safe. They were wrong Romy Elusfa in Ampatuan and Richard Lloyd Parry, Asia Editor He knew that powerful and ruthless people wanted him dead and that he was risking everything by standing for election — but to one practical challenge at least, Ismael Mangudadatu thought he had a solution. If he went in person to register as a candidate he would be inviting an attack by his enemies — the Ampatuan clan who have a near-monopoly on elected posts in the region. Instead, after consultation with his family and advisers, Mr Mangudadatu decided to send his wife and two sisters. The local police refused to provide an escort and the Philippines Army declined a request for protection. But how much harm could befall a group of women? For good measure, the two family lawyers who were women and Mr Mangudadatu’s aunt — who was pregnant, like one of his sisters — went along for the ride with other supporters and relatives. As a further safeguard, 27 journalists were invited. “Under our tradition, Muslim women are respected,” Mr Mangudadatu said. “They should not be harmed, just like innocent children and the elders. They will not harm us if journalists are watching.” Related Links Philippines leader 'shot massacre victims' Philippines massacre suspect arrested At 9.30am on Monday six minibuses began the drive from the town of Buluan to the provincial capital of Shariff Aguak. “This is women power in action,” Eden, Mr Mangudadatu’s sister, was heard to say. “Let’s help our men chart a better future for the province.” Within hours, she and her companions were dead. They had been bound, macheted, shot and buried in a mass grave. It is believed that some were raped. Political killings have been a part of life for centuries in the Philippines, and the southern island of Mindanao is the most violent of all. The attack, in which 57 people were killed, has raised questions about the relationship between the gangster clans such as the Ampatuan family and the highest levels of the Philippines metropolitan elite. Yesterday Andal Ampatuan Jr, the son of one of the most powerful men in Mindanao, was charged with seven counts of murder. “He was the one who gave the instructions,” Agnes Devanadera, the Justice Minister, said. “He was among those ... who killed the victims.” Until they were expelled this week, Mr Ampatuan and his father were important members of the ruling party of Gloria Macapagal Arroyo, the President. Her Government has also moved against members of its security forces suspected of being complicit in the violence. According to the national police chief, Jesus Verzosa, six senior officers, including the provincial chief and his deputy, twenty officers of the Ampatuan police station and about four hunded members of a militia loyal to the Ampatuan family are in custody. Many Filipinos remain sceptical about the prospects for improvement. “He [Ampatuan Jr] can be a sacrificial mouse to spare the leopards behind the crime,” one Maguindanao man told The Times. “The most powerful people among the Ampatuans are still in government.” Three journalists survived the attack because they stopped at their hotel when the convoy was setting out. “The lady at the front desk told us that a motorcycle-riding man armed with a pistol came to ask for the names of journalists who checked in at the hotel,” said Aquiles Zonio, of the Philippine Daily Inquirer. They tried calling colleagues, but the hold-up had already taken place. The convoy was stopped about an hour into its journey, near the town that bears the Ampatuan family name. Some victims were able to send texts reporting that they had been stopped by about a hundred armed men. Police Chief Superintendent Felicisimo Khu said: “Twenty-four corpses were all killed by a firing squad. They were buried in six layers. Every layer is covered with earth, making it more difficult for the retrieval operations. I have asked myself why one of them has no underwear.” Ms Devanadera said: “Even the private parts of the women were shot at. It was done practically to all the women. All the women had their zippers undone. The pants of some were pulled down. We have yet to determine whether they were raped.” According to Mr Khu, the gunmen intercepted two vehicles with six people who happened to be travelling on the same road at the same time, and killed them too. “Some sustained multiple gunshot wounds — as many as eight,” said Benito Molina, a forensic examiner at the scene. “To judge from the blood, some of the corpses may have been buried while still alive.” Cooking pots belonging to the killers were found at the scene and they had taken with them a mechanical digger bearing the name of the local government. Its engine was still running when soldiers arrived. The brutality appears to have backfired on the Ampatuan clan: the intensity of public anger will ensure that no politician in Manila will court their friendship publicly in the election in May. It is little compensation for the loss of his family, but Mr Mangudadatu’s election prospects have been strengthened. “Only death can stop me from running,” he said yesterday when he filed his candidature for the regional governorship of Maguindanao, which is held by the brother of Mr Ampatuan Jr. “This symbolises our freedom. I hope this will be the start of our liberation.” The scale of the massacre may be unique, but its story — of violence, clans and corruption — is repeated across the Philippines. Father Eduardo Vasquez, a priest in Shariff Aguak, said: “If powerful and equally armed families like the Mangudadatus were killed in such a barbaric manner, how much more for the ordinary civilians who have already been traumatised by the war?” Clan power Andal Ampatuan Sr has four wives and thirty children. He has a private army of several hundred, permitted under a presidential executive order His extended family dominates the region’s politics. One son, Zaldy, is governor of the Muslim Mindanao The provincial capital Maganoy was renamed Shariff Aguak after Mr Ampatuan’s late father One of his sons and a nephew are its mayor and vice-mayor

Bukid Apo

Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Photo by Romy Elusfa

News Archieve

Popular Posts

Popular Posts

About Me

Blog Archive